Bathroom guideUpdated 2 min read

Walk-in shower vs tub: which fits your bathroom?

The short answer

A walk-in shower is easier to step into, easier to clean and usually makes a small bathroom feel bigger, which is why it is the most common choice when nobody uses the tub. Keep a tub if you bathe young children or love a soak, and keep at least one in the house if you plan to sell to families.

Walk-in shower with marble-look walls, a recessed niche and a glass panel
From our jobs

Start with how you use the bathroom

The right answer is about the people who use the room, not the room. Ask:

  • Does anyone take baths, or bathe small children here?
  • Is stepping over a tub wall getting harder for someone in the house, or will it soon?
  • Is this the only bathroom with a tub?
  • Do you plan to stay in the house, or sell in the next few years?
Illustration of a bathtub with a shower and curtain
IllustrationA tub with a shower: the most common setup in older hall bathrooms.

Why people choose a walk-in shower

  • Easier and safer to step into. A low curb, or no curb at all, instead of a tub wall to climb over. Grab bars and a bench fit naturally.
  • Easier to clean. Large tiles or panels and a glass panel instead of a tub, a curtain and its corners.
  • More open. Clear glass lets the eye run to the back wall, so a small bathroom feels bigger.
  • Room for what you want. A wider shower, a niche for bottles, a hand shower on a slide bar.

The building code sets a minimum: a shower at least 30 inches across with at least 900 square inches of floor.1 A walk-in shower that replaces a standard tub usually has far more than that.

When to keep the tub

  • Young children. Bathing small kids is easier in a tub.
  • Soaking. If a bath is how you unwind, you will miss it.
  • Resale. In the National Association of Home Builders' 2024 buyer survey, having both a shower and a tub was among the top-rated bathroom features, rated highly by 78% of buyers.4 In its earlier survey, 27% of buyers said they did not want a primary bath with only a shower stall.5 If this bathroom has the only tub in the house, think twice before removing it.
  • Space for both. In a larger primary bathroom, a separate shower and a freestanding tub give you both.

What the change involves

Angi puts the 2026 national average cost to install a walk-in shower at $9,000, with most homeowners spending $6,000 to $12,000.2 In the 2026 Houzz Bathroom Trends Study, a tub was removed in 26% of bathroom projects, and 79% of those homeowners used the space for a bigger shower.3

Replacing a tub with a walk-in shower in the same spot is usually the simplest version: the drain stays close to where it is. The old tub and surround come out, the floor is checked and repaired, the drain and the valve are adjusted, a waterproof shower is built and tiled, and glass goes on last. Moving the shower to another wall means more plumbing work in the floor.

A curbless entry needs the floor lowered or built up so water stays in the shower, which adds work under the floor.

Sources

  1. 2021 International Residential Code, Chapter 27, Section P2708 Showers (adopted in the Virginia Residential Code), International Code Council, 2021.
  2. How Much Does a Walk-In Shower Cost? (2026 Data), Angi, updated October 30, 2026.
  3. 2026 U.S. Houzz Bathroom Trends Study, Houzz Research, September 30, 2026.
  4. Home Buyers Are Looking for Amenity-Loaded Kitchens and Bathrooms (What Home Buyers Really Want, 2024), NAHB Eye On Housing, September 10, 2024.
  5. In the Bath, First-Time Buyers Really Want Both a Shower & Tub, NAHB Eye On Housing, March 30, 2022.

Figures are the published averages and medians of these sources, not Cuevas Construction prices. Your project's cost comes from an in-home estimate.

Before and after

The same bathroom, tub or shower

An illustration: the tub comes out and a walk-in shower goes in where it was.

Gains
An easy step in, glass, more open space
Loses
The bath, and the tub for young children
Keep in mind
At least one tub in the house helps at resale
Illustration, before: a bathroom with a tub and curtain; after, the same bathroom with a walk-in shower and glass panel
Illustration. Drag the handle to compare.

Compare

Shower or tub, side by side

The same questions, answered for each.

Most common

Walk-in shower

An open shower with a low or no curb.

Getting in
A low curb or none.
Cleaning
Fewer corners; glass and large tile.
Small children
Harder to bathe them.
Soaking
Not possible.
Small bathroom
Feels bigger with clear glass.
Resale
Fine, if another bathroom has a tub.

Tub with shower

A tub you can also shower in.

Getting in
Step over the tub wall.
Cleaning
More corners, a curtain or doors.
Small children
Easiest.
Soaking
Yes.
Small bathroom
Takes the full width.
Resale
Expected in at least one bathroom.

Not sure? We can talk it through at the estimate, with the rest of your house in mind.

FAQ

Shower and tub questions

Does removing a tub hurt resale value?

It can if it is the only tub in the house: in the National Association of Home Builders' 2024 survey, 78% of buyers rated a bathroom with both a shower and a tub highly. If another bathroom keeps a tub, a walk-in shower is usually welcome.

Is a walk-in shower safer than a tub?

Usually. There is no tall wall to step over, and grab bars, a bench and a hand shower fit easily. A curbless entry is the easiest of all.

Can a walk-in shower fit where my tub is now?

In most cases, yes. A standard tub space is larger than the minimum shower size, and the drain stays close to where it is.

How long does a tub-to-shower change take?

It depends on the tile, the glass and what is found under the old tub. We give you the schedule with the estimate.

Free in-home estimate

Thinking about trading the tub?

We will look at the bathroom, talk through the options and give you a detailed estimate at no cost.